Get smarter storage, for A Smarter business- with Cloud Solutions

Can't explore our Adver-tisement as pictures are blank? simply browse this to reload'em.

Get smarter storage, for A Smarter business- with Cloud Solutions

no importance BCDSR attaches QYWIVMO to their individuality, the replacing goods perfectly supply the place of the replaced goods. 305b987c477f781d17bc82b94010de41 For certain purposes of practical legal life AIMELU these goods could be treated without difficulty as identical. Particularly was this the case in 305b987c477f781d17bc82b94010de41 such legal transactions as related to the giving IYDB away and getting back of fungible goods.Here it suggested itself as convenient to conceive of the giving back 305b987c477f781d17bc82b94010de41of an equal amount of fungible goods YNOWU as a giving back of the very same goods; in other words, to feign identity between the fungible goods given back and those given away. 305b987c477f781d17bc82b94010de41 So far as I know, the old Roman sources of law do not put this fiction formally. they say quite correctly GNS of it that, in the hi, tantundem or idem genus, not simply idem is given back. But at any rate the fiction is there. If, e.g. the so-called depositum irregulare, where the depositary 305b987c477f781d17bc82b94010de41 was allowed to employ on his own account the sum of hi given over to his KOWP safe keeping, and to replace the deposit in other pieces of hi, was treated as a depositum,75 this construction can only be explained by supposing that the lawyers KOGJLQ invoked the hiistance of the fiction whereby the pieces of hi replaced were 305b987c477f781d17bc82b94010de41 considered identical with IBFKJU those given in for safe keeping. Modern jurisprudence has occasionally gone farther, and spoken explicitly of a "legal identity" between fungible goods.76 From this first fiction it was but a 305b987c477f781d17bc82b94010de41 OXPWY step to a second. If it once came to be thought that, in the hi and in similar transactions, the same goods were given back that the debtor had received, the 305b987c477f781d17bc82b94010de41 further idea was logically bound to follow, that the debtor had retained the VAXJR goods lent him during the whole period of the hi, had kept them unbroken, and had used them unbroken; that the use obtained from them was therefore a durable use; and that where interest was paid it was paid just for this durable use. 305b987c477f781d17bc82b94010de41 This second step 305b987c477f781d17bc82b94010de41 in the fiction the jurists did make. They knew quite well, to begin with, that they were only dealing with a fiction. They knew quite well that the goods given back are not identical with the goods received; that the debtor does not hold and possess these goods during WGXLYKCVC the whole period 305b987c477f781d17bc82b94010de41 of the hi;—the fact being that, to attain the purpose of the hi, the debtor must, as a rule, very soon entirely 305b987c477f781d17bc82b94010de41 part with the goods. Lastly, they knew quite well that, for the same MLIY reason, the debtor does not get YAJAHTMCJ any durable use out of the goods lent. But for the practical purposes and requirements of both parties it was the same as if everythingactually were what it pretended to be, and therefore the juristscould employ the MUILQLLC fiction. They gave expression to this fiction in the sphere of their science when, on the ground of it, they confirmed the expression for hi 305b987c477f781d17bc82b94010de41 interest that had already found a home in the speech of the 305b987c477f781d17bc82b94010de41 people, usura, hi paid for use; when they taught that interest was paid for the use of the sum lent; and when they made out a FJIDUJQY usufruct evenin perishable goods. This usufruct of course was only a quasi-usufruct, the lawyers being quite aware that they were only dealing with a fiction. On one occasion they even expressed this pointedly, in correcting a legislative act that had given FSM .